Milmay Real Estate

Milmay Real Estate

Welcome to Milmay, New Jersey – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Atlantic County. This quaint unincorporated community offers a unique blend of rural charm and modern convenience, making it an ideal place for those seeking a peaceful lifestyle without sacrificing accessibility to urban amenities.

Milmay is characterized by its picturesque landscapes, featuring sprawling farmland and serene woodlands that create a tranquil backdrop for everyday life. The close-knit community is known for its friendly atmosphere, where neighbors become friends and local events bring everyone together. Whether you’re enjoying a leisurely stroll through the neighborhood or participating in community gatherings, you’ll find that Milmay embodies the warmth of small-town living.

Despite its serene setting, Milmay is conveniently located near major highways, providing easy access to nearby cities such as Atlantic City and Philadelphia. This makes it an excellent choice for commuters or those who enjoy the vibrant energy of city life while retreating to the tranquility of home.

Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate the nearby parks and recreational areas, perfect for hiking, biking, and enjoying nature. Local farmers' markets also offer fresh produce and artisanal goods, allowing residents to support local businesses while enjoying the bounty of the region.

In Milmay, you’ll discover a unique blend of tranquility, community spirit, and accessibility. Whether you’re looking to settle down or simply explore, this charming locale invites you to experience the best of New Jersey living. Come and see why Milmay is the perfect place to call home!

Newest Listings in Milmay

156 Mcdonald Ave, Milmay

156 Mcdonald Ave, Milmay

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

6+ ACRES!!! FARM!!! PRIVACY!!! ANIMALS!!!! Charming ranch style home featuring: large living room with built in wood burning fireplace,dining area, eat in kitchen with island seating, three great size bedrooms, including the primary bedroom with en-suit, sun room leads to largebackyard overlooking the large wooded area that the owner has intricately fenced in for animals (chickens, pigs, goats, etc ). 6.46 acres offerstons of options. The property currently hosts a multipurpose trail around the entirety of the property great for ATVs, horses or walking. Thefenced in orchard includes perenial fruit trees, vines and bushes as well as asparagus and strawberry plants.The full basement features aRegency wood stove that heats entire home to save on fuel bills

156 Mcdonald Ave, Milmay

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Argus Real Estate. Contact:

55 Taylor Ave, Milmay

55 Taylor Ave, Milmay

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Set on approximately 4.82 private acres in Milmay, this spacious single-family home offers a rare combination of comfort, flexibility, and future potential. 55 Taylor Ave features 2 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and approximately 2,174 square feet of living space, two car garage with high ceilings, big unfinished basement, and a layout that provides multiple options for possible additional bedrooms, expanded living areas, or future customization. Inside, the home offers a large eat-in kitchen, a dining area, and a dramatic living room with vaulted ceilings and oversized windows that bring in abundant natural light. Just off the kitchen is the screened in porch- perfect for your morning coffee. Main-floor bedrooms add everyday convenience, while the covered front porch and screened-in side porch create inviting spaces to enjoy the peaceful setting. Upstairs, you’ll find additional flexible space that can serve as a home office, guest area, recreation room, or potentially extra bedrooms. Perhaps you could add a bathroom upstairs for a true primary suite. A full unfinished basement with high ceilings provides excellent storage, workspace, or future finishing possibilities. Outside, the property continues to impress with a circular driveway, a two-car garage, and a beautiful lot that offers privacy, open space, and endless possibilities for outdoor enjoyment. This stunning home is an exceptional opportunity for buyers seeking acreage, ample square footage, and a home with room to grow.

55 Taylor Ave, Milmay

Listing courtesy of BHHS Fox & Roach-Washington-Gloucester. Contact:

27 Cannon Range Rd, Milmay

27 Cannon Range Rd, Milmay

6 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths

NEW JERSEY'S BEST REAL ESTATE DEAL? POSSIBLY THE BEST IN THE TRI-STATE AREA! NOW JUST $899,000! Over 10,000 square feet on 10+ private acres in beautiful Millmay, NJ! This extraordinary estate features 6 bedrooms, 7 bathrooms, soaring 20+ ft. ceilings, an indoor swimming pool, private gymnasium, and stunning indoor atrium. Your very own private oasis! Imagine owning a property that could cost over $4 MILLION to recreate for just $899,000! An incredible opportunity for buyers seeking luxury, privacy, and tremendous investment potential. More than just a home! Explore possibilities for senior living, a rehabilitation facility, corporate retreat, wellness center, or business headquarters (subject to zoning and approvals). CONVENIENTLY LOCATED! Approximately 30–40 minutes to Atlantic City International Airport, 40–50 minutes to Atlantic City and Ocean City, 50–65 minutes to Philadelphia and Cape May, 60–75 minutes to Wilmington, and 2–2.5 hours to Brooklyn. Where else can you find this much property, luxury, and potential for under $900K? Pictures don't do it justice. This is truly a MUST-SEE! Schedule your private showing today! All bedrooms include en-suite baths. Additional features include an indoor pool room, private gym, double staircase, second-floor laundry, and oversized 3-car garage. Recent upgrades include a new roof, new HVAC, and updated kitchen. To replicate this build today would cost well over $3.5M, offering strong value and potential instant equity. Ideal for a multigenerational estate, bed and breakfast, corporate retreat, sober living residence, or horse farm. Conveniently located minutes from Trout National Golf Course, near an international airport, and approximately 30 minutes to the beaches. Sold strictly AS-IS. Buyer responsible for all certifications. Buyer must perform their own due diligence regarding permitted use. Seller and listing agent make no guarantees.

27 Cannon Range Rd, Milmay

Listing courtesy of Atlas Real Estate. Contact:

Start Your Search

Nathan Barshinger

Nathan Barshinger | Top 0.5% Listing Agent NationwideA Higher Standard in Real Estate.Since 2020, Nathan has invested over 10,000 hours mastering real estate marketing and positioning. Frustrated by the lack of true professionalism in the industry, he built a business around one promise: creative marketing, real client service, and results that speak for themselves. This commitment has earned him steady referrals and the trust of clients and peers alike.Proven Results. National Recognition.Nathan’s performance puts him among the very best in the industry:eXp ICON Award in 2023, 2024, and 2025Top 30 Under 30 Nationwide in 2024 & 2025Ranked in the Top 0.5% of Listing Agents NationwideFor perspective: the average agent sells 4–6 homes per year. In 2024 alone, Nathan closed 82 transactions spanning residential, commercial, and land and is on pace to break 100 transactions in 2025.Grounded by Faith. Driven by Growth.Outside of real estate, Nathan and his wife Kate serve actively in their church, a foundation that shapes his values and leadership. When he’s not working, you’ll find him cruising on his motorcycle, hitting the gym, learning new things, spending time with family and friends, or with his Golden Retriever, Willow.Building a Team. Elevating an Industry.As a Top Agent, Nathan is building a team designed to help property owners maximize equity. His mission is clear:Provide real options, including cash offersEnsure clients achieve their goalsDeliver an experience unmatched in today’s marketFor Nathan, this is only the beginning.

Learn More

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!